This essay Regulate and Reform Euthanasia has a total of 1176 words and 7 pages.
Regulate and Reform Euthanasia
One of the landmark cases that involve euthanasia is that
of Karen Ann Quinlan. Quinlan, a twenty-one year old New Jersey
resident, overdosed on pills and alcohol in 1975. She was rushed
to the hospital where her physical condition gradually
deteriorated to a vegetative state. The doctors determined she
had no chance of recovery. Before the coma Karen said that if
anything ever happened that would leave her physically and
mentally incompetent, without any chance of recovery, she would
not want to be kept alive by "extraordinary medical procedures,"
notes Derek Humphry. Karen\'s parents sought religious counsel
from their priest. They were told that the Catholic religion
allows the removal of extraordinary care if the patient was in a
terminal condition. Karen\'s parents requested she be removed from
the respirator. The hospital denied their request. The Quinlans
then directed their request to the court. The superior court
denied their request. They took their request to the New Jersey
Supreme court where the decision was reversed. Karen was
removed from the respirator. To everyone\'s surprise, Karen began
breathing on her own and lived another ten years (Humphry 107).
The Quinlan case brought to the forefront patients\' desire
to die a proud, quiet death. It also brought to the forefront
the complications caused by the advancement of medical technology
("Euthanasia"27). Euthanasia has been practiced in Eastern and
Western culture since the beginning of civilization. The
capability of medical technology to extend life (as demonstrated
by the Quinlan case) has made the issue of euthanasia more
complicated. Individuals should be allowed to "die with dignity"
in the event of terminal illness if he or she wants it.
Terminating a patient\'s life is much more merciful than allowing
him or her to die a slow painful death from illness. Those who
oppose legalizing euthanasia and assisted suicide say that this
could lead to involuntary killing of the aged and infirm. I
agree that there may be danger of abuse and that the vulnerable
need to be protected; therefore, I support passing legislation
that monitors and regulates physician assisted suicide. The
demand for legislation in support of legalized euthanasia for the
terminally ill has been an issue since the beginning of the
century. According to Derek Humphry in Ohio in 1906, a Bill
proposing to legalize euthanasia was presented to the Ohio
legislature. The bill was defeated by nearly 80% of those voting.
Opponents said the bill would have presented away for doctors to
cover up their mistakes. Opponents also say that the bill would
have provided a means for families to get rid of relatives who
were a nuisance and give fortune seekers a shortcut to
inheritance. Although the bill was defeated, the idea it
generated still lives on (Humphry 12).
Opponents of euthanasia often refer to the atrocities and
attitudes in Nazi Germany for reasons not to support euthanasia.
An article in the Progressive describes the essay "Permitting the
Destruction of Unworthy Life" written in Germany in 1920, by
Alfred Hoche. In the essay he proposes getting rid of the "\'dead
weight existence of incurables in Germany.\'" By "\'incurable\'" he
meant those who were mentally and emotionally disabled (Who 34).
When the Nazis took power in Germany in 1933, as explained in
"Euthanasia and the Third Reich" an article in HISTORY TODAY,
they took Alfred Hoche\'s concept of euthanasia and used it to
rationalize sterilization of those with "hereditary" illnesses.
They also used the "euthanasia programme" to kill mentally and
physically handicapped children and adults. Eventually they used
this policy as justification for killing Jews, homosexuals, and
others (Burleigh 11). Many believe that this kind of murder can
happen again if euthanasia is legalized. However, the senseless,
atrocious killings in Germany cannot be compared to carefully
regulated policies that will allow euthanasia in selective cases.
Such an extreme comparison should not prevent a merciful
euthanasia policy for the terminally ill in unbearable pain who
request it. As people began forgetting World War II and the
atrocities of Nazi Germany, interest in "assisted suicide" and
euthanasia was restored. To understand the controversy of
euthanasia and assisted suicide, one must understand the
difference between the two terms. Euthanasia involves the
administering of the life taking measure; whereas, assisted
suicide provides the means or instructions to the patient who
intends to kill him or herself. Physicians who are used to saving
lives are being asked to end patients lives. The request for
"death with dignity" is very popular.
In a 1991 Gallop Poll, nearly 60 percent of those
interviewed said that a person has the "moral right" to end his
or her life when the person "has a disease that is incurable."
Sixty-five percent said "yes"
Topics Related to Regulate and Reform Euthanasia
Euthanasia, Medical ethics, Disability rights, Assisted suicide, Aktion T4, Voluntary euthanasia, Legality of euthanasia
Essays Related to Regulate and Reform Euthanasia
EuthanasiaEuthanasia submitted by Ryan Ames Euthanasia, as defined in Microsoft Encarta 95\', is the act of painlessly ending the life of a person for reasons of mercy. This paper will examine the history of euthanasia and the issues surrounding assisted suicide. There are as many reasons for supporting assisted suicide as there are reasons to not support it. However one looks at this topic, we will all be confronted with this in one way or another. Medical technology has allowed life to be sustained lo
Euthanasia Term PaperEuthanasia Term Paper A considerable size of society is in favor of Euthanasia mostly because they feel that as a democratic country, we as free individuals, have the right to decide for ourselves whether or not it is our right to determine when to terminate someone\'s life. The stronger and more widely held opinion is against Euthanasia primarily because society feels that it is god\'s task to determine when one of his creations time has come, and we as human beings are in no position to behave
EuthanasiaEuthanasia Should a patient who has lost all powers of reasoning and who lives like a vegetable, totally hopeless and helpless, a terminal case who only wants to die, be forced to live? The number of people who are asking this question increases each day. Although the official position of the medical profession is to maintain life indefinitetely, regardless of the condition of the patient, but with certain cases, euthanasia should be administered. We are living in an age of medical miracles. Med
Euthanasia - Immoral or Human Right?Euthanasia - Immoral or Human Right? Recent debates over active euthanasia, killing a terminally ill patient, in Holland, has risen the question whether euthanasia is immoral or a simple human right. Doctors seem to have no doubt. They made an oath. The definition of Euthanasia depends on whether it is active or passive. Active Euthanasia i only allowed in Holland, and it means that the doctor takes direct measures to put a patient to sleep, whereas passive Euthanasia only involves stopping pi
Euthanasia Mercy KillingEuthanasia Mercy Killing Sue Rodriguez has reminded us all of our own mortality and our need to think carefully about the kind of society we want to live and to die in. Sue Rodriguez was known through the media, and her well spoken and eloquent speeches. People painfully in support of what she believed in, watched as her strength was sapped by the devastating disease (amyotrophic lateral sclerosis), and we were moved by her clear thought and her bravery as a person facing death. Here was a woman
EuthanasiaEuthanasiaEuthanasia, is one of the most controversial issues of our time. This diver se issue raises many questions such as: how should decisions be made, and by whom? What should be determined as a matter of law and what left a matter of discretion and judgment? Should those who want to die, or who are in a persistent vegetative state be allowed to die voluntarily? Who should decide: the patient, the physician, the courts, or the families? The pro-euthanasia arguments turn on the individual
EuthanasiaEuthanasia An eighty-seven year old grandmother on a respirator, a newborn child with AIDS, and a father in a coma; all put to death by respectable doctors with the O.K. of their families. But is it really 3O.K.ý? Euthanasia, or doctor-assisted suicide, has become as common as jumping off of a fifteen story building or taking a gun to one1s own head. Certainly society frowns upon suicide, but yet putting an old lady or a man in a coma to death is being accepted every day. Society knows that suic
When is Now? Euthanasia and MoralityWhen is Now? Euthanasia and Morality David Yu Ewrt 1A-9C 12-19-94 The third night that I roomed with Jack in our tiny double room, in the solid-tumor ward of the cancer clinic of the National Institute of Health in Maryland, a terrible thought occurred to me. Jack had a melanoma in his belly, a malignant solid tumor that the doctors guessed was the size of a softball. The doctors planned to remove the tumor, but they knew Jack would soon die. The cancer had now spread out of control. Jack, abou
Euthanasia In CanadaEuthanasia In Canada There is considerable debate today, both among the public and the politicians, about euthanasia. While the government is hesitatant to venture into morals and ethics, it appears that euthanasia is gaining more press coverage, in light of the Sue Rodriguez and Robert Latimer cases. Indeed, the issue is difficult to resolve, and despite few advances, the government has enacted penalties in the Criminal Code to punish assisted suicide. Without reservation, euthanasia is illegal
Why I Believe In Voluntary EuthanasiaWhy I Believe In Voluntary Euthanasia Why I Believe In Voluntary Euthanasia There are at least two forms of suicide. One is \'emotional suicide\', or irrational self-murder in all of it complexities and sadness. Let me emphasis at once that my view of this tragic form of self-destruction is the same as that of the suicide intervention movement and the rest of society, which is to prevent it wherever possible. I do not support any form of suicide for mental health or emotional reasons. But I do s
The Case for Euthanasia: Should Physician-AssistedThe Case for Euthanasia: Should Physician-Assisted Suicide be Legalized? Throughout the twentieth century, major scientific and medical advances have greatly enhanced the life expectancy of the average person. However, there are many instances where doctors can preserve life artificially. In these cases where the patient suffers from a terminal disease or remains in a persistent vegetative state or PVS from which they cannot voice their wishes for continuation or termination of life, the quest
Regulate and Reform EuthanasiaRegulate and Reform Euthanasia One of the landmark cases that involve euthanasia is that of Karen Ann Quinlan. Quinlan, a twenty-one year old New Jersey resident, overdosed on pills and alcohol in 1975. She was rushed to the hospital where her physical condition gradually deteriorated to a vegetative state. The doctors determined she had no chance of recovery. Before the coma Karen said that if anything ever happened that would leave her physically and mentally incompetent, without any chance of
EuthanasiaEuthanasia It is conceivable, that life can deteriorate to the point where persons lose their dignity and self-respect and are unable to communicate; life in such a form no longer meets meets the basic criteria of human-ness. (O\'Keefe, A1) Under these circumstances only should Euthanasia be practiced and then only passively (pulling the plug). Dutch Death, Euthanasia, doctor assisted suicide, whatever you want to call it, it should not be legalized. People should live their lives for as l
Euthanasia: The Right to DieEuthanasia: The Right to Die Thesis: Euthanasia should be legalized so, if we ever have a loved one that is suffering and death is certain, that we have the choice to ease their pain if they want. I. Introduction A. Examples showing why euthanasia is receiving national attention. B. A summary of reasons offered by those opposed to euthanasia is given. C. A summary of reasons offered by those in favor of euthanasia is given. D. Transition into my argument. II. Body A. A person has the right to di
EuthanasiaEuthanasia Public opinion for euthanasia and doctor assisted suicide has always been mixed. A poll that was taken by the Gallup Organization in Canada during July 1995 proves that people are starting to see the advantages of euthanasia. The first question that was asked was: When a person has an incurable disease that is immediately life threatening and causes that person to experience great suffering, do you, or do you not think that competent doctors should be allowed by law to end the patien
EuthanasiaEuthanasiaEuthanasia is one of the most acute and uncomfortable contemporary problems in medical ethics. Is Euthanasia Ethical? The case for euthanasia rests on one main fundamental moral principle: mercy. It is not a new issue; euthanasia has been discussed-and practised-in both Eastern and Western cultures from the earliest historical times to the present. But because of medicine\'s new technological capacities to extend life, the problem is much more p Euthanasia is a way of granting mercy-b
Assisted SuicideAssisted Suicide Over the past ten to twenty years a big issue has been made over a person1s right to commit suicide or not. The American courts have had to deal with everything from assisted suicides to planned suicides, and whether the constitution gives the American people the right to take their own lives or whether it says they have the power to allow someone else to take their lives. They have had to determine in some cases whether or not homicide charges needed to be brought up and others